Best Davids Toothpaste Alternatives – 2025

June 25, 2025 Sean Fillmore

Davids Natural Toothpaste has built a loyal following for its bold peppermint flavor, sustainable packaging, and whitening claims. But for some users, the experience can feel a little too intense — from the strong taste to the use of stevia and xylitol. If you’re looking for a gentler, more balanced option, here are the best Davids toothpaste alternatives in 2025 — led by Real Skin Care’s naturally mild and effective coconut oil formula.

Quick Look at the Best Davids Toothpaste Alternatives

Real Skin Care Toothpaste – Creamy and fluoride-free with coconut oil
Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste – Organic and essential oil based
Redmond Earthpaste – Mineral-rich and ultra-clean formula
Tom’s of Maine Children’s Toothpaste – Mild and accessible
Hello SLS-Free Toothpaste – Trendy and easy to find
Risewell Toothpaste – Hydroxyapatite-powered and dentist-formulated

1. Real Skin Care Coconut Oil Toothpaste – A Naturally Gentle Alternative

If Davids feels too bold or sweet, Real Skin Care’s Coconut Oil Toothpaste is a breath of fresh air. Our formula is fluoride-free, SLS-free, and alcohol-free — crafted from purified spring water, organic coconut oil, baking soda, and a hint of peppermint. It’s made for real people who want a clean mouth without the overpowering flavor or foaming agents.

This toothpaste supports oral health by nourishing the mouth’s natural microbiome. Coconut oil is known for its antibacterial properties, while the gentle, creamy texture makes brushing a pleasure — not a chore. Handcrafted in the USA in small batches, it’s the ideal choice for families seeking real simplicity without compromise.

Shop Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste

2. Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste – Organic with a Herbal Touch

Dr. Bronner’s offers a fluoride-free toothpaste made with certified organic ingredients. It’s low-foam, naturally flavored, and clean — though the runny texture and herbal flavor profile don’t appeal to everyone. Still, it’s a great pick for ingredient-conscious shoppers who want a gentler option.

3. Redmond Earthpaste – The Minimalist’s Dream

Earthpaste uses just a handful of ingredients, including bentonite clay, water, sea salt, and essential oils. There’s no glycerin, fluoride, or sweeteners of any kind. It’s about as clean as you can get, but its earthy taste and texture are very different from traditional pastes — which can be a dealbreaker for some.

4. Tom’s of Maine Children’s Toothpaste – Mild, Simple, and Easy to Find

For those seeking a mild option, Tom’s children’s toothpaste (yes, even for adults!) offers a safe, non-irritating formula. It’s free of fluoride and artificial flavors, though it does contain glycerin and xylitol. A good transition toothpaste for those with sensitivity to strong flavors like Davids.

5. Hello SLS-Free Toothpaste – Trendy and Accessible

Hello’s fluoride-free options come in fun flavors and sleek packaging, appealing to a younger audience. It avoids SLS and dyes, but still includes sweeteners like erythritol and stevia, which can cause irritation in some users — especially when used multiple times daily.

6. Risewell Toothpaste – Science-Backed, But Not for Everyone

Risewell includes hydroxyapatite and a full suite of natural ingredients to promote enamel strength and oral health. It’s well-respected in the dental world, but the ingredient list is much longer than Real Skin Care’s and includes essential oils and stevia. A good choice if you want performance, but not if you’re going ultra-clean.

Why You Might Want a Davids Alternative

Davids offers some great benefits, but its intense flavor, higher cost, and inclusion of sweeteners like xylitol and stevia don’t work for everyone. If you’re ready to simplify your routine with a clean, family-safe alternative that doesn’t sacrifice performance, Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste is worth the switch.