Best Dr. Bronner’s Toothpaste Alternatives – 2025

June 23, 2025 Sean Fillmore

Dr. Bronner’s is known for its organic, all-purpose products — and their toothpaste is no exception. But while the brand has built trust over decades, some users find their toothpaste too thin, too mild, or simply not quite the right fit for their oral care routine. If you’re looking for a toothpaste that’s just as natural but offers a more balanced experience, here are the best Dr. Bronner’s alternatives in 2025 — led by Real Skin Care’s nourishing coconut oil formula.

Quick Look at the Best Dr. Bronner’s Alternatives

Real Skin Care Toothpaste – Coconut oil-based and organic, with a smooth texture
David’s Natural Toothpaste – Bright mint flavor and recyclable packaging
Redmond Earthpaste – Ultra-minimalist with bentonite clay
Risewell Mineral Toothpaste – Hydroxyapatite-based with a foamy feel
Tom’s of Maine Botanically Bright – Natural, but includes stevia and glycerin
Jack N’ Jill Toothpaste – A good fit for sensitive mouths or children

1. Real Skin Care Coconut Oil Toothpaste – Organic, Creamy, and Family-Safe

Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste is perfect for those who want the purity of Dr. Bronner’s — but with a smoother, more familiar brushing experience. Our formula blends purified spring water, organic coconut oil, baking soda, and a light peppermint essence. It skips synthetic sweeteners, fluoride, SLS, and alcohols, making it ideal for kids and adults alike.

Unlike Dr. Bronner’s watery consistency, this formula delivers a creamy feel that’s gentle yet effective. The coconut oil naturally supports a healthy oral microbiome, while the minimalist ingredient list ensures no surprises. It’s handcrafted in the USA and packaged with care for a clean you can count on.

Shop Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste

2. David’s Natural Toothpaste – Peppermint Power and Sleek Packaging

David’s Natural Toothpaste is popular for its strong flavor and aluminum tube. It’s SLS-free, fluoride-free, and uses stevia and xylitol as sweeteners. While it’s more foamy and bold than Dr. Bronner’s, it may be too intense for users who prefer a more subtle profile.

3. Redmond Earthpaste – Simple, Salty, and Clay-Based

Redmond Earthpaste skips all the extras: no glycerin, no foaming agents, and no synthetic flavors. It uses bentonite clay and sea salt for its cleaning action. If you like Dr. Bronner’s minimalist ingredient list but want an even more stripped-down experience, Earthpaste could be for you — though the texture takes getting used to.

4. Risewell Mineral Toothpaste – Modern and Dentist-Backed

Risewell includes hydroxyapatite for enamel support and a lightly foaming texture. It’s free from fluoride and SLS, but the ingredient list is longer than most natural brands. Some may prefer to skip lab-derived alternatives in favor of whole ingredients like those found in Real Skin Care’s version.

5. Tom’s of Maine Botanically Bright – Accessible with Caveats

Tom’s offers natural options that are widely available in stores. The Botanically Bright formula features peppermint and stevia, along with a blend of botanical extracts. However, the presence of glycerin and natural flavors may not work for ingredient purists.

6. Jack N’ Jill Natural Toothpaste – Mild and Great for Kids

Jack N’ Jill is a top choice for kids and sensitive users who find even Dr. Bronner’s too strong. It’s fluoride-free, SLS-free, and flavor-forward without synthetic ingredients. While not as robust in performance, it’s a safe pick for daily use across all ages.

Why Choose a Dr. Bronner’s Alternative?

While Dr. Bronner’s brings incredible sourcing ethics and organic values, the texture, taste, and performance don’t suit everyone. Whether you’re looking for a creamier feel, more pronounced flavor, or better ingredient balance, Real Skin Care’s coconut oil toothpaste offers a refreshing upgrade that’s just as clean — but far more enjoyable to use.