Risewell has gained a reputation for its modern, dentist-developed formulas — especially its use of hydroxyapatite as a fluoride alternative. But while it sounds cutting-edge, hydroxyapatite isn’t for everyone. Some users report gritty textures, higher prices, or ingredient sensitivities. If you’re searching for a cleaner, simpler option that still supports strong, healthy teeth, here are the best Risewell toothpaste alternatives in 2025 — starting with our top pick from Real Skin Care.
Quick Look at the Best Risewell Alternatives
- Real Skin Care Toothpaste – Organic, hydroxyapatite-free, and made with coconut oil
- David’s Natural Toothpaste – Whitening and fluoride-free with stevia
- Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free – Widely available, but some synthetic ingredients
- Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste – USDA Organic and essential oil-based
- Redmond Earthpaste – Minimalist clay-based option with no foaming agents
- Jack N’ Jill Kids Natural Toothpaste – Gentle, safe, and sweetener-free for kids
1. Real Skin Care Coconut Oil Toothpaste – Gentle, Pure, and Effective
If you’ve tried Risewell but prefer fewer ingredients, Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste is the clear winner. Our formula is designed for purity and comfort — with just purified spring water, organic coconut oil, baking soda, and a light peppermint finish. It’s free from fluoride, hydroxyapatite, SLS, alcohols, and synthetic sweeteners — perfect for sensitive mouths or ingredient-conscious families.
Coconut oil’s natural antibacterial benefits help support a healthy mouth microbiome without the need for synthetic or lab-derived compounds. And because it’s handmade in the USA in small batches, our quality control and transparency are second to none.
Shop Real Skin Care’s Organic Coconut Oil Toothpaste
2. David’s Natural Toothpaste – Sustainable and Whitening
David’s is a well-known alternative that skips fluoride and SLS while offering a strong peppermint flavor and whitening benefits. It’s made in the USA and comes in a recyclable aluminum tube. The downside? It includes xylitol and stevia, which can be irritating for some users — and the texture isn’t as creamy as coconut oil-based pastes like Real Skin Care’s.
3. Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free – Widely Available but Not Always Clean
Tom’s of Maine offers multiple fluoride-free options, and they’re easy to find in stores. However, many versions still contain questionable ingredients like carrageenan or sodium lauryl sulfate. It’s a good transitional brand, but not ideal if you’re focused on completely natural oral care.
4. Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste – Organic and Low-Foam
Dr. Bronner’s paste is made with organic oils, aloe, and silica, offering a very mild, low-foam experience. It’s a decent alternative if you’re avoiding hydroxyapatite and prefer herbal ingredients, but some find the texture too runny and the mint flavor too subtle.
5. Redmond Earthpaste – Minimalist and Clay-Based
Redmond Earthpaste uses bentonite clay, sea salt, and water — nothing more unless you opt for a flavored version. It’s one of the most minimalist brands on the market, which makes it great for ingredient purists. However, the texture and taste take some getting used to, especially for kids.
6. Jack N’ Jill Kids Toothpaste – Perfect for Sensitive Young Mouths
If you’re looking for a gentle formula for toddlers or young kids, Jack N’ Jill is a solid option. It’s fluoride-free, SLS-free, and doesn’t contain any artificial colors or flavors. While designed for children, many adults with sensitivities appreciate its mildness. That said, it doesn’t offer the oral health benefits of coconut oil found in Real Skin Care’s toothpaste.
Why You Might Want a Risewell Alternative
Hydroxyapatite is a rising trend, but it’s not a must-have for healthy teeth — especially when natural alternatives like coconut oil can support oral hygiene without synthetic substitutes. Real Skin Care offers a back-to-basics solution: fewer ingredients, full transparency, and a product made with families in mind.