Best Tom’s of Maine Alternatives – 2025

Published: June 19, 2025 Updated: August 9, 2025 Sean Fillmore

Natural Toothpaste, Zero Question Marks

Skip SLS, artificial sweeteners, and harsh preservatives. Our Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste is handmade for families who want clean ingredients.

Shop Natural Toothpaste

Tom’s of Maine has been a staple in the natural toothpaste space for decades — but for many families today, “natural” isn’t enough. From hidden additives to inconsistent ingredient sourcing, some shoppers are now looking for brands that go further: truly clean, truly simple, and truly effective. Below are the best Tom’s of Maine alternatives in 2025, with our top pick from Real Skin Care.

1. Real Skin Care Coconut Oil Toothpaste – Clean and Gentle for All Ages

Real Skin Care’s Coconut Oil Toothpaste is the minimalist choice for anyone who wants a formula that’s actually natural — not just labeled that way. It features organic coconut oil, purified spring water, baking soda, and a light touch of peppermint. That’s it. No SLS, no parabens, no synthetic sweeteners, and no harsh preservatives. It’s handmade in the USA and gentle enough for kids and sensitive mouths.

The coconut oil helps fight bacteria naturally, while the clean ingredient deck supports a healthy oral environment. Because it’s fluoride‑free and alcohol‑free, it’s safe for daily use without over‑drying or irritation.

Ready for a gentler brush?

Try our Fresh Mint Natural Toothpaste — SLS‑free, alcohol‑free, and family‑friendly.

Add to Cart

2. Boka Ela Mint Toothpaste – Fluoride Alternative Vibe

Uses hydroxyapatite (fluoride alternative), SLS‑free, modern flavor profile. Includes glycerin and essential oils — fine for many, but not the most minimalist.

3. Hello Sensitivity Relief – Affordable and Accessible

Widely available and budget‑friendly; SLS‑free. Uses stevia/erythritol for sweetness, which some ingredient‑focused shoppers prefer to avoid.

4. Risewell Toothpaste – Dentist‑Backed

Hydroxyapatite‑based to support enamel; SLS‑free and low‑foam. More complex ingredient list than Real Skin Care’s simple formula.

5. Dr. Bronner’s All‑One Toothpaste – Organic and Herbal

USDA organic approach; aloe, coconut oil, silica, essential oils. Very low foam and a thinner texture — a preference thing.

6. David’s Natural Toothpaste – Modern and Eco‑Minded

Recyclable aluminum tube; SLS‑free, fluoride‑free. Strong mint and sweeteners (xylitol/stevia); not as minimalist as some prefer.

Why Look for a Tom’s of Maine Alternative?

Some “natural” pastes still include SLS, carrageenan, or synthetic flavorings. If you’re seeking a simpler label with recognizable ingredients and a gentle feel, moving to a cleaner, more transparent formula can make a noticeable difference — especially for sensitive mouths. Real Skin Care keeps it truly simple.

Natural Clean, Minty Fresh

See why families switch to Real Skin Care Fresh Mint — no SLS, no synthetic sweeteners, no harsh preservatives.

Shop Now